YouTube Imams & Instagram Shaykhs – Are They Helping or Hurting Islam?
In today’s digital age, we’re just one click away from a fatwa, tafsir, or Islamic lecture.
But not every “Shaykh” with a beard and a blue checkmark is a true scholar.
So, are these YouTube imams and Instagram preachers helping or hurting the Ummah?
Let’s take a deeper look through the lens of the Qur’an, Sunnah, and the words of real scholars.
🎥 The Rise of Digital Dawah: A Double-Edged Sword
There’s no doubt — technology has made Islamic knowledge more accessible.
Millions now learn about Islam through:
- YouTube lectures
- TikTok reminders
- Instagram reels
- Telegram or WhatsApp dawah groups
✅ Positives
- People learn the basics of Islam fast
- Converts find Islam through relatable content
- Youth reconnect with faith in simple language
- Authentic scholars like Mufti Menk, Omar Suleiman, Bilal Philips, Yasir Qadhi, and others are now more reachable
📖 "Whoever calls to guidance will have a reward equal to those who follow him."
— Prophet ﷺ (Sahih Muslim)
🚫 But There’s a Serious Danger
Not all “preachers” online are grounded in the Sunnah.
Some are:
- Self-proclaimed scholars with no ijazah (Islamic certification)
- Motivational speakers who twist Hadith
- Misguided or extreme groups with hidden agendas
- Promoting fame, not knowledge
💬 Ibn Sireen said:
“This knowledge is religion. So look to whom you take your religion from.”
(Source: Sahih Muslim, Muqaddimah)
❌ Examples of Those Against the Sunnah
Here are signs a preacher might be going against the Sunnah:
- Openly mocking the Salaf (pious predecessors)
- Mixing music and Islamic messages
- Promoting ideas like gender fluidity, halal dating, or “everyone’s truth is valid”
- Claiming dreams and visions as sources of revelation
- Constant begging for donations while living in luxury
- Overuse of comedy and drama for Islamic reminders
📖 “Say: If you love Allah, then follow me (the Prophet), and Allah will love you…”
— Surah Aal Imran 3:31
✅ Real Scholars Stick to These
Look for scholars and teachers who:
- Stick to Qur’an and authentic Sunnah
- Quote classical scholars like Ibn Taymiyyah, Imam Nawawi, Imam Malik
- Are known by other trustworthy scholars
- Have studied at known Islamic universities (e.g., Madinah, Azhar, Darul Uloom)
- Are humble and avoid fame
⚠️ Reminder: The most famous in the Dunya are not always the most accepted by Allah.
👀 How to Tell Who to Trust?
Ask yourself:
- Are they quoting Qur’an & Sahih Hadith?
- Do they call you to Allah, or to themselves?
- Do they promote humility or arrogance?
- Do real scholars acknowledge them?
- Are they consistent or changing views with trends?
💭 Final Thought
Not all influencers are scholars.
Not all scholars are on social media.
And not all popular Islamic content is safe.
Stay guided by the Sunnah and those grounded in ilm (knowledge).
“The scholars are the inheritors of the prophets.”
— Prophet ﷺ (Abu Dawud, authentic)
💬 Let’s Discuss:
Have you ever been confused by conflicting online Islamic advice?
How do you verify which preachers to trust?
Follow our blog for more clarifications on modern Islamic issues. 🕌
Comments
Post a Comment